my blog

Thursday 15 July 2010

Du choix des villes organisatrices des RMLL

Cela a été annoncé pendant les RMLL 2010 (dont je viens de parler): les RMLL 2012 auront lieu à Liège. J'ai un petit grain de critique à ajouter à cette nouvelle... Mais je tiens à préciser dès à présent que je suis ravi que les RMLL quittent le territoire français (cela les rendra un peu plus mondiales) et que je ne doute pas un instant que le dossier de candidature réalisé par l'équipe de Liège était de grande qualité.

Après avoir discuté avec plusieurs personnes, je m'interroge sur la méthode de sélection de la ville qui accueille les RMLL : il n'y a pas eu, à ma connaissance, d'appel à candidatures et de manière générale, le processus décisionnel est quelque peu opaque. Cela me dérange un peu, donc autant en discuter. Et ayant participé à la sélection de villes organisatrices du GUADEC par le passé, je sais que ce n'est pas toujours facile de décider. On peut tout de même tenter d'améliorer la visibilité depuis l'extérieur :-)

Première étape : en farfouillant un peu (j'ai trouvé un lien sur cette page), je suis tombé sur le site du comité des RMLL, qui offre quelques informations, et notamment la composition du comité ainsi que quelques (maigres) informations en ligne sur comment candidater. C'est quelque chose d'un peu méconnu, je pense, donc allez lire tout cela si vous avez le temps (et que cela vous intéresse, évidemment ;-)).

Le manque d'appel à candidature est, à mon avis, le plus problématique : il semble dommage de ne pas en avoir, en particulier dans la mesure où au moins un groupe aurait aimé candidater. J'avoue avoir du mal à comprendre pourquoi il n'y en a pas eu, mais j'imagine qu'on a pu penser qu'il fallait décider pendant les RMLL, et qu'il n'y a pas eu le temps de réaliser cet appel avant. Était-ce cependant vraiment nécessaire de prendre une décision dès à présent ? Attendre deux ou trois mois aurait par exemple été possible, sans pour autant poser un problème à l'équipe organisatrice choisie. Peut-être y a-t-il une autre explication que je ne connais pas, mais j'avoue avoir du mal à imaginer qu'elle justifierait de sauter l'étape de l'appel à candidatures.

En ce qui concerne l'opacité du processus, le principal problème est qu'il n'y a aucune documentation sur les éventuels candidats, ni de réels critères permettant d'expliquer pourquoi une ville serait préférée à une autre. Par exemple, comment le choix est-il effectué si les dossiers sont tous de qualité ? Ou est-ce envisageable qu'une ville bénéficie d'une sorte de bonus afin d'aider au développement de la communauté dans la région ? Je ne demande évidemment pas que la décision soit prise en public — je peux concevoir sans problème que c'est le type de décision qu'on souhaite prendre en étant complètement à l'aise, sans avoir à se censurer sur ses propos. On peut aussi imaginer la possibilité de recueillir des commentaires auprès de la communauté sur les différentes candidatures, par exemple. Le fait est qu'ouvrir un peu le processus pourrait aider à améliorer les futures candidatures, sans pour autant nuire.

Pourquoi est-ce que je me pose ces questions et pourquoi est-ce que cela me dérange un peu ? Tout simplement parce que les RMLL sont un évènement important pour la communauté francophone, et que s'il est possible d'améliorer un peu une partie de l'organisation, cela ne peut que résulter en des rencontres encore plus utiles à tous :-)

Et vous, qu'en pensez-vous ?

Back from Bordeaux: RMLL 2010

At the end of last week (assuming it's okay to say that the end of the week starts on Wednesday ;-)), I went to Bordeaux for the RMLL 2010: this is simply the biggest community-oriented event in France. Since I've been traveling often lately and I'm going to leave for GUADEC later this month, I chose to not attend the whole event and to only be there for 3-4 days instead of the full 6 days experience.

Booths

The Mandriva people had a really great idea this year: they proposed to try to share a booth among distributions, and thanks to them, we were able to have an openSUSE presence on the first few days. So walking down the hall where all the booths were, you could see Debian, Fedora, Mandriva and openSUSE all together. Of course, we shared more than just the booths: we're all friendly people after all, so we chatted a lot and enjoyed being together. I really want to thank Michael from Mandriva for pushing me to make sure openSUSE would have a place here.

One funny tidbit is that we never requested a GNOME booth since all the GNOME people coming to the event knew they'd be busy with various other tasks (and I didn't feel I could handle both a GNOME and an openSUSE booth...). However, we still got one this way ;-) It was merged with the distributions booth, and I just put GNOME stickers all around to make sure our GNOME love gets distributed!

openSUSE Booth

openSUSE Booth at the RMLL

The picture above shows the openSUSE booth during the week-end, which was much better organized than during the first few days! I don't think I have a picture of the first booth, so you can't really compare, but it's probably better this way ;-) Thanks to Michael (the openSUSE one) for sending us DVD, stickers and a few t-shirts: it helped make the booth more interesting!

Radio RMLL

A small group of volunteers was broadcasting a radio show during the whole event: Radio RMLL. And guess what? The world-famous Frédéric Péters was part of that team! The archives are online, and you can make fun of various distributions by listening to the distribution roundtable that Frédéric organized: hopefully, the fact that we knew each other made it not too boring!

Talks

Like for Linuxtag, I delivered two talks: one about GNOME 3.0, and the other about contributing to openSUSE. While both were in the Development track, I thought it'd be better to talk about GNOME 3.0 from the user perspective since that's what people were expecting; on the other hand, for openSUSE, I wanted to show that contributions to a project like openSUSE aren't necessarily technical contributions.

One thing that struck me (and the other GNOME people) is that we get much more excitement when we propose a talk about GNOME 3, than when we were trying to present the latest development in GNOME during the 2.x era. It's not the first time we noticed this (it happened in all previous events where we had some GNOME 3 bits too), but the contrast is so important that I'm now convinced the version number is much more important from a marketing perspective than from a technical one. Definitely something to keep in mind for our future roadmap, and for when we'll think about GNOME 4.

I also got interviewed for Linux Pratique about GNOME. During the discussion, I discovered the editors are based in Sélestat, which is a small city a few kilometers away from where my grand-mother lives. Small world.

The people

The best thing about an event like the RMLL is of course all the people you meet. It was good to see old friends (Didier, Frédéric, Michael, Alexandre, just to give a few names) as well as new faces! Being nasty people, we all made fun of each other's projects, but we also learnt the latest news about all those projects and their contributors. Oh, and we managed to bring someone living in London to an Irish pub in Bordeaux — is there a better place to enjoy food in France?

It was interesting to see that there were GNOME-friendly people (not just GNOME contributors) all around, although we weren't present with a real booth. And I was obviously glad to meet some members of the french-speaking openSUSE community: Guillaume, Julien, Jimmy and Jean-Luc. I think it's one of the first time (if not the first) where we managed to make openSUSE really visible during an event, and it was successful. It's a good step in making openSUSE-fr an even more vibrant group!

Come next year!

The event was not perfect, though: I think most people would agree that the wifi could have worked much better (it was down way too often), that having the event split between various building that weren't really close to each other was suboptimal, and that the weather was, well, way too hot ;-) But I'm sure the organizers did their best, and they even succeeded in getting a few drops of rain on Friday!

So not perfect, but it's still one of the two or three times in the year where you can connect with most of the free software community in France, and if only for this reason, that's a must-go event here. Oh, and next year, it'll be in Strasbourg: that's another reason everybody should come!

Monday 12 July 2010

Question existentielle du jour

Quel est le plus grave :

  • le fait que je reconnaisse immédiatement la musique de Retour vers le futur III jouée par ZZ Top qui passe 5 secondes dans l'émission citée ci-dessus ?

Je m'interroge sérieusement...

Thursday 1 July 2010

The true Lennart

We all know Lennart. No need to mention his last name since there's only one (well, nobody can pronounce his last name anyway). As we all know, Lennart looks like this:

The Lennart we know

The Lennart we know (note his red t-shirt, did you ever see him with a non-red t-shirt?)

But at LinuxTag, I discovered he was trying to hide the truth, even though I still have no idea why. Yes, ladies and gentlemen, the Lennart we know is only an illusion! Yes, he was pretending all the time! And yes, to confuse all of us, he's sometimes hiding behind another picture! I know it will come as a shock to everyone, and I know it will be difficult to admit, but here is the true Lennart:

The true Lennart

The true Lennart (yes, it's the same person: look at the t-shirt!)

Wednesday 30 June 2010

LinuxTag 2010: Attack of the Geekos!

It's finally time to talk about LinuxTag 2010. It was my third time there, and this year was the best so far, at least for me! And that's most probably because of how amazing our openSUSE booth turned out to be! Or maybe it's because of the invasion of the Geekos?

openSUSE Booth

We certainly didn't have a big slot for out booth, but oh boy... it ended up big! Our booth was always filled with people, who, I guess, got attracted by the touchscreens we have. But attracting people is of no good if you can't get them interested. We did various demos on the touchscreens, but our small secret ingredient were the workshops: four times a day (and sometimes even more), people could sit down in our booth to participate in a session on various topics — those ranged from learning Inkscape, to creating your first package in the Build Service, via playing together with GNOME Shell. That really worked out well, especially at it helps getting the visitors more involved in the discussion.

Stuffed Geeko

The world-famous Geeko

Many thanks to Jan (who had to suffer my presence way too much, I'm sure!) and Michael for the organization of our booth!

GNOME Presence

As mentioned in my previous post, there was no GNOME booth at the event. And it didn't go unnoticed: I met various people wondering about this. So I surely hope the German community will make sure it doesn't happen again next year!

Even without a booth, we managed to get a relatively good presence during the event. Of course, it was easy to stumble upon some GNOME people — our friends from Openismus, of course, but also Stormy, Lennart, Tobias and more. Some of us were giving a GNOME-related talk, and Stormy and I participated in a RadioTux interview, so our footprint was present :-)

Talks

I didn't attend many talks. Actually, I think I only attended Stormy's one — Stormy is good at making you raise your hand to keep you connected to what she says — and Lennart's talk about Surround Sound.

The talk Johannes and I gave went quite well, with around 50 people in the room, which is quite good since it was not a keynote and it was in English. We had good questions from the audience, which at least means they were not totally asleep ;-) Generally speaking, I'm nearly always pleasantly surprised by the reaction of people when they get to see GNOME Shell for the first time: I somehow always expect that I have to carefully explain some of the design decisions, but it's apparently unneeded. Most of the persons I meet are glad we're doing something different and seem to be ready to try the change!

Wireframe Geeko

A wilder Geeko, built by yours truly

The live A-Z Guide to openSUSE Contribution was the second talk I was involved in, with Henne. With 26 letters in 30 minutes, you might think it's plenty of time. But we actually had to rush to talk about everything! The goal was really to show that there are tons of areas where people can contribute in openSUSE, while most people think it's just packaging. And 26 was our limit, but I'm sure we could have gone on and on for a long time: everyone can help (packaging, sure, but also presence at events, support, bug triage, helping with screencasts, contributing to a positive atmosphere inside the project, etc.). Most of our items were actually not specific to openSUSE and are common to most free software projects... I really like the format Henne found for the talk; that's something I'll keep in mind for future talks.

Meeting people

LinuxTag is also a great opportunity to sit down with a few people. We had both GNOME and KDE people (Stormy, Claudia, Frank and I) all sitting around a table to discuss the organization and the bids for Desktop Summit 2011. Thanks to our experience with GCDS, we have a good basis for the organization since we know what worked well and what didn't. We came out with an aggressive timeline to take a decision during this summer, which should help the organization team start the work early.

Johannes, Stormy and I also chatted about the GNOME developer tools and what we can do to improve our story there. That's something where the Foundation wants to help, but this can only happen if our community wants to improve them, of course. We wondered for a bit while our own developers don't use a tool like Anjuta. Is it just a matter of habits? Or is it missing some features? (I know that, in my case, I just can't live without vi-like keybindings...)

c-base

On Friday evening, the GNOME folks were invited to a barbecue organized by LXDE people at c-base. I had heard about c-base for quite some time, but it was a first for me. Lennart insisted that I should go through the main entrance to truly enjoy the experience, so Andre guided me there (okay, he nearly got lost ;-)). And indeed, I can only recommend that you do the same if you ever go to visit c-base. And I know for sure I'm human now!

The highlight of the evening was undoubtedly the learning of a new card game: skat. I watched people play, and it somehow felt a bit familiar; that's because it's somehow similar to belote (although it's also completely different, but well...). Tobias offered to teach me, and it all went well. I mean, it made sense. And then I was explained how the bidding works. I'm still trying to figure out why it works this way ;-) I understand how it works, but... it just feels totally arbitrary with no reason. I was glad that I managed to help Stormy and Kat learn it later on (well, Stormy had understood most of the rules already by watching the game). So we were three complete beginners playing skat at some point :-)

Attack of the Geekos

But the best thing about LinuxTag was the omnipresence of Geeko, the openSUSE chameleon. I must admit I enjoy Geeko, and that's something I sorely miss in GNOME: our GNOME foot is nice, but that's not the same. We should probably talk more about our beloved Rupert, I guess. (And I still don't have any Rupert at home, that's a tragedy for me!)

As seen in the pictures in this post, we had several versions of Geekos, and I managed to bring some of them home. One of the workshop we had everyday at the openSUSE booth consisted of creating your own Geeko-ified object: the wireframe Geeko was one of them, but people also had the opportunity to create a pin, a shopping bad and a magnet. You can recognize Henne's creative mind behind all this.

But that's not all, we had a balloon clown, who created tens of balloon Geekos:

Our Balloon Clown

Our amazing balloon clown by Thomas Schmidt (see more pictures)

And the balloon Geeko can survive a flight trip, here's mine a few days after the event:

Balloon Geeko

A light Geeko

The stuffed Geekos we had were highly-demanded: everybody loves it! And I understand, really: how can you not love it? At some point, I took 3 or 4 of them and hid them in various places in the venue. Actually, they were not really hidden, but integrated: it just felt like they belonged there. And I'm sure it made some people smile ;-)

Yes, LinuxTag was big this year, and I'm happy that Novell let me go to the event! I hope you'll want to come next year, now :-)

- page 10 of 119 -

by Vincent